About
Teaching
Research
Presentations
Blog

Toby Handfield

About
Teaching
Research
Presentations
Blog
 

Toby Handfield is a Professor of Philosophy in the School of Philosophical, Historical, and International Studies at Monash University.

  • Curriculum vitae

  • Books

  • More information about current projects in research and teaching

  • A complete list of published papers

  • Collaborators

Contact: [email protected]

 
 
Blog
Lessons for social epistemology from evolutionary biology
February 10, 2020
Lessons for social epistemology from evolutionary biology
February 10, 2020

What lessons might epistemologists draw about the possibilities for cooperation in online networks, from evolutionary biology and evolutionary game theory in particular?…

Read more →
February 10, 2020
Kantianism is false
May 29, 2018
Kantianism is false
May 29, 2018

To the extent that universalisability is a nice idea, it works well for the classic social dilemma: the prisoners' dilemma (or its multi-player equivalent, the tragedy of the commons). In such cases, there is one "cooperative" action which, if everyone performed it, would be best for the collective. But it is always better for each individual to abstain from cooperating. In such cases, we cannot rationally will that everyone abstain: that would defeat our rational aims. So there is a duty to cooperate.
 

Read more →
May 29, 2018
Collective knowledge is easy — Ignorance is hard
May 20, 2018
Collective knowledge is easy — Ignorance is hard
May 20, 2018

Although collectives manage to do something that resembles the functional package of agency overall, they achieve this without any clear, isolatable analogue of beliefs, intentions, and the like. So we cannot identify any analogous failure of those "organs", even if we are confident that the package as a whole has failed. Collectives can be agents, and they can be subject to failures of agency. But their failures may not be classifiable as either ignorance or weakness of will.

Read more →
May 20, 2018
Philosophy is not serious about being a discipline
October 20, 2017
Philosophy is not serious about being a discipline
October 20, 2017

… the speaker in a research presentation can expect to benefit more than the audience. The idea is somehow that the audience is there to ask questions which will help the speaker sharpen the argument, that the presentation will be an opportunity for enhancing the prestige of the speaker and generally satisfying his or her ego. All good for the speaker, to be sure; but the audience won't really learn much.

Read more →
October 20, 2017
A good exit
October 10, 2017
A good exit
October 10, 2017

Deliberate extinction of the species would be the morally heroic option, if ...

Read more →
October 10, 2017
When good norms turn bad
September 21, 2017
When good norms turn bad
September 21, 2017

Why are people so darn cooperative? Among economists, a popular answer has been: social norms, enforced by peer punishment. In a new paper, we devised an experiment to investigate the dark side of this mechanism. Social norms can be destructive, and punishment can lock societies into bad norms...

Read more →
September 21, 2017
Egalitarianism about expected utility - a counterexample to Voorhoeve and Fleurbaey
August 18, 2017
Egalitarianism about expected utility - a counterexample to Voorhoeve and Fleurbaey
August 18, 2017

Voorhoeve and Fleurbaey have erred in their suggestion that this hybrid currency is the appropriate object of distributive concern.

Read more →
August 18, 2017
An experiment for decision theorists
August 15, 2017
An experiment for decision theorists
August 15, 2017

Our hunch is that the extreme parameters used in Newcomb's original case are bad news for the reliability of the intuitions it generates.

Read more →
August 15, 2017
Good news for moral intuition mongers
April 7, 2017
Good news for moral intuition mongers
April 7, 2017

… if anything, Demaree-Cotton is overestimating the susceptibility of moral intuition to framing effects.

Read more →
April 7, 2017
The best thing I learned from Michael Sandel
April 4, 2017
The best thing I learned from Michael Sandel
April 4, 2017

... there is a palpable change in the atmosphere in the class. One can see the students sit a little more erect in their seats, their attention sharpened

Read more →
April 4, 2017
Lucky starts in academia
March 28, 2017
Lucky starts in academia
March 28, 2017

… it might be useful, however, for students thinking about pursuing an academic career to see some actual data on how hard it is to get publications.

Read more →
March 28, 2017
Contemplating the mortality of our species
March 6, 2017
Contemplating the mortality of our species
March 6, 2017

If we knew that the human species would not exist for very long after our own deaths, should it change how we live our lives now?

Read more →
March 6, 2017
Video feedback on student assignments
February 20, 2017
Video feedback on student assignments
February 20, 2017

My experiments with making short videos to provide students with feedback on their written work.

Read more →
February 20, 2017
Reflections on the Flipped Classroom
April 30, 2015
Reflections on the Flipped Classroom
April 30, 2015

Have our classrooms already “flipped”?

Read more →
April 30, 2015
Presenting research: old and new
September 25, 2013
Presenting research: old and new
September 25, 2013

When giving a paper at a conference, or at a research seminar, should the work presented be complete or in progress?

Read more →
September 25, 2013
Presentations
Sacred values and signaling
September 29, 2018
Sacred values and signaling
September 29, 2018

early experimental data testing hypothesis that sacred value attitudes serve as a signal…

Read more →
September 29, 2018
Intuitions in decision theory: Empirical evidence
June 13, 2018
Intuitions in decision theory: Empirical evidence
June 13, 2018
Read more →
June 13, 2018
The Coevolution of Sacred Values and Religion
May 10, 2018
The Coevolution of Sacred Values and Religion
May 10, 2018
Read more →
May 10, 2018
Blog RSS
Back to Top

Powered by Squarespace