Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Critical Security Studies

description3,824 papers
group27,274 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Critical Security Studies is an academic field that examines security beyond traditional military and state-centric perspectives. It critiques dominant security paradigms, emphasizing the social, political, and economic dimensions of security, and explores how power dynamics shape security practices and discourses, often focusing on issues of identity, human rights, and global inequalities.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Critical Security Studies is an academic field that examines security beyond traditional military and state-centric perspectives. It critiques dominant security paradigms, emphasizing the social, political, and economic dimensions of security, and explores how power dynamics shape security practices and discourses, often focusing on issues of identity, human rights, and global inequalities.

Key research themes

1. How do critical approaches reconceptualize security beyond traditional state-centric paradigms?

This theme explores how critical security studies challenge and expand the conventional understanding of security that primarily focuses on state and military concerns. It investigates the intellectual foundations, theoretical premises, and epistemological shifts introduced by various critical schools—such as the Copenhagen, Aberystwyth, and Paris schools—emphasizing concepts like securitization, broadening, deepening, and opening of security studies. The significance lies in reshaping security studies into a more reflexive, interdisciplinary field that accounts for social, political, and ethical dimensions, thereby influencing both academic inquiry and political practices.

Key finding: Identifies the evolution of European critical security studies through a networked collective of scholars challenging traditional 'schools' and demonstrating cross-fertilization between approaches. It emphasizes dismantling... Read more
Key finding: Advances the critical agenda in security studies by introducing international political sociology concepts such as materialities, practices, and micro-politics, which move away from deepening and widening security to focus on... Read more
Key finding: Argues for a third axis of critical security studies beyond broadening and deepening—‘opening’—which re-interprets security as a practice and emphasizes contestations, everyday enactments, and the politics of security... Read more
Key finding: Critiques post-structuralist critical security studies for limiting their own critical potential by focusing predominantly on security practices without sufficiently situating them within broader strategies of control. It... Read more

2. How can critical security studies engage with regional and decolonial contexts to diversify epistemologies and political agency?

This theme investigates critical security studies’ engagement with non-Western and marginalized perspectives, particularly in the Middle East and Global South. It focuses on efforts to decolonize security knowledge, recognize diverse linguistic and cultural contexts, and reconcile dominant Euro-American paradigms with local experiences and histories. The scholarly pursuit includes pedagogical practices, epistemological pluralism, and critique of hegemonic security discourses, aiming to expand the scope and inclusivity of critical security scholarship and empower alternative security imaginaries and political agency.

Key finding: Develops a decolonial pedagogy focused on the Middle East and North Africa, emphasizing linguistic politics, translation, and situated praxis. It challenges Western security paradigms by incorporating postcolonial IR and... Read more
Key finding: Advances the project of decolonizing security studies by critically examining systemic global racial hierarchies, colonial legacies, and North-South inequities that shape knowledge production and define legitimate security... Read more
Key finding: Challenges the methodological individualism in vernacular security studies by empirically demonstrating how Ukrainian civil society collectively produces shared security meanings transcending individual perspectives during... Read more

3. What are the implications of ontological and existential security theories for understanding state behavior and contemporary global threats?

This theme centers on the integration of ontological security (the psychological need for consistent identity) and existential security frameworks into security studies, analyzing how these concepts influence state identities, foreign policy, and global security structures. It critically examines issues like nuclearism, the limits of national security, and the challenges posed by anthropogenic existential threats such as nuclear war and climate change. The investigation provides a deeper understanding of the tensions between state behavior, identity maintenance, and the pursuit of human survival in an unstable international system.

Key finding: Applies Lacanian psychoanalysis to Turkish foreign policy, highlighting how ontological insecurities stemming from historical trauma and identity ambivalence with the West shape Turkey's security perceptions and practices. It... Read more
Key finding: Defines existential security as a paradigm addressing humanity’s collective survival against threats like nuclear warfare, positioning it as distinct from but intertwined with national security. The paper critiques the... Read more
Key finding: Illuminates hierarchies in the international nuclear security discourse, showing that dominant powers like the US and close allies control access to knowledge and legitimation of nuclear security, thus framing who is... Read more
Key finding: Proposes a novel theoretical framework disaggregating the state into multiple power centers with distinct motivations and goals, challenging the traditional unitary actor assumption in IR. DST conceptualizes rulers maximizing... Read more

All papers in Critical Security Studies

Five years after the February 2021 state of emergency, ASEAN has shifted from an emergency response toward a sustained restriction of Myanmar's high-level participation whose legal coherence now warrants scrutiny. This article examines... more
Since the XIX century, the project on the Bridge over the strait of Messina is a long-lasting obsession that entails symbolic, political and economic reasons that intertwine with different phases of capitalism and the Italian national... more
Principles and rules of international law are of great significance for the establishment of effective international security. International security in the broad sense of the term constitutes a specific system of intergovernmental... more
In the context of the current US and Israeli wars on Iran (and Lebanon) and during what appears to be the eclipse of US primacy, we brought together a group of scholars with expertise on the “weak” states of the Middle East for a Project... more
The nature of espionage has undergone a profound transformation in the age of artificial intelligence, big data, and hyper-connectivity. Unlike traditional spying—which required physical access, human agents, and tangible documents—modern... more
Policing is heavily experience-oriented and a practical person’s niche. However, high-quality policing requires more than experience because change outpaces experience; it requires the principles of ethics. Inculcating the principles of... more
tention of public administration. A problematic aspect is the lack of clarity of interpretation of the main category and identification of components of state security, which slows down the formation of effective mechanisms of public... more