Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Ethics of War

description363 papers
group4,031 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
The ethics of war is a branch of moral philosophy that examines the moral principles governing the conduct of war, including the justification for going to war (jus ad bellum), the ethical conduct within war (jus in bello), and the post-war responsibilities (jus post bellum), focusing on issues such as justice, rights, and humanitarian considerations.
lightbulbAbout this topic
The ethics of war is a branch of moral philosophy that examines the moral principles governing the conduct of war, including the justification for going to war (jus ad bellum), the ethical conduct within war (jus in bello), and the post-war responsibilities (jus post bellum), focusing on issues such as justice, rights, and humanitarian considerations.

Key research themes

1. How do legal and moral frameworks define and regulate permissible conduct and justifiable harm in wartime?

This theme explores the interrelation and tensions between international laws of war and moral principles guiding combatant conduct and civilian protection. It examines foundational principles like distinction, proportionality, and precaution, clarifies ambiguities in legal formulations, and evaluates responsibilities that soldiers and commanders hold in adhering to moral-laden legal restrictions. This research is vital for understanding permissible uses of force, liability for war crimes, and reconciling just war theory with international humanitarian law in practical and ethical warfare.

Key finding: Haque bridges legal and moral theories by defending established legal principles such as civilian immunity while clarifying ambiguous ones like proportionality and precaution. He critiques the misunderstanding that... Read more
Key finding: Miller develops a nuanced account rejecting the moral equality of all combatants by emphasizing the principle of reciprocity as a particularist moral norm. He argues that combatants fighting an unjust war lack the same moral... Read more
Key finding: Kallhoff challenges conventional just war theory’s approach by focusing on soldiers' moral agency, arguing for a detailed moral evaluation of individual acts of killing beyond the standard jus in bello framework. She shows... Read more
Key finding: This paper situates evolving AI technologies in warfare within an ethical framework that problematizes autonomous killing and stresses human responsibility. It argues that current AI lacks reflexive moral agency, thus... Read more
Key finding: Van Goozen and Miller extend just war theory to account for animals, highlighting significant gaps in normative frameworks that almost entirely ignore non-human casualties and harms in armed conflict. They argue for expanding... Read more

2. What are the diverse theological and philosophical perspectives informing ethical attitudes toward war, peace, and violent conflict?

This theme investigates how Christian, Islamic, and Orthodox theological doctrines, as well as broader philosophical critiques, shape ethical understandings of war and peace. It includes historical evolution, scriptural bases, and doctrinal developments such as pacifism and just war theory, and also reflects on statecraft, moral responsibilities, and political theology. Understanding these perspectives is crucial for analyzing religiously rooted moral frameworks that influence warfare justification, conduct, and reconciliation.

Key finding: This paper maps Christian doctrinal evolutions from Old and New Testament narratives to early Church pacifism and the development of Just War Theory via Augustine and Aquinas, focusing on balancing nonviolence and justice. It... Read more
Key finding: The author challenges stereotypes of Eastern Orthodox political theology as simply harmonizing church-state relations, showing instead its anarchistic theocratic dynamics rejecting sacralization of imperial power or violence.... Read more
Key finding: This essay analyzes how Vladimir Putin manipulates selective imperialist, nationalist, and Great Patriotic War historical narratives to legitimize Russian aggression against Ukraine. It reveals the instrumentalization of... Read more
Key finding: Focusing on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, this article explicates the moral dilemmas amid widespread civilian suffering and challenges the suspension of moral judgment in wartime atrocities. It problematizes the rhetoric... Read more

3. How do technological advances, especially AI and software, transform the ethical and operational landscape of contemporary warfare?

This theme addresses the repercussions of incorporating artificial intelligence, robotics, and information technology into military operations, including autonomous weaponry, cyber warfare, and information manipulation. It interrogates the moral status and responsibility attributed to synthetic agents, the ethical challenges posed by algorithmic decision-making in lethal contexts, and the evolving definitions of agency and accountability. These inquiries support developing governance structures and normative frameworks responsive to technological disruptions in the character and conduct of war.

Key finding: This article offers a conceptual framework distinguishing moral agency among individual humans, institutions, and synthetic AI agents within international relations. It argues current AI lacks reflexive autonomy required for... Read more
Key finding: The chapter identifies the Russia-Ukraine conflict as potentially the first fully software-defined war, driven by AI and robotic technologies integrated into precision targeting, surveillance, cyber warfare, and autonomous... Read more
Key finding: Explores ethical challenges related to deployment of AI in military robotics, including autonomous weapons systems and cyberattacks. It calls attention to the anthropomorphic fallacy in legal debates and proposes an... Read more
Key finding: Employing the Free Energy Principle from neuroscience and systems theory, this paper argues that war is inherently maladaptive as it disrupts internal stability and harmony with the environment. It prescribes diplomatic and... Read more

All papers in Ethics of War

This study investigates discourse issues and strategies in Martin Luther's "A Mighty Fortress Is Our God" and John Monsell's "Fight the Good Fight", examining how language constructs ideological meaning within Christian hymnody. Although... more
This article analyzes the musar (virtue/character-focused) teachings of Rabbi Amy Eilberg, the first woman ordained as a rabbi within Conservative Judaism, in relation to the historic nineteenth century Musar movement and broader... more
Objective: To assess how threat imminence shapes public judgments of deadly force used by police and by civilians, and whether the public believes the imminence requirement currently applies to police. Methods: We fielded a nationally... more
تهدف هذه الدراسة إلى تحليل الانتقادات القرآنية المو ّجّهة لبني إسرائيل، وذلك من خلال الدراسة المقارنة بين تفسيرين هامين لم يكونا إلا مدرسة تُُعد أجيال مؤمنة قوية لديها فقها بواقعها وهما: تفسيري محمد عزة دروزة، وسيد قطب. وتنطلق الدراسة من... more
The abysmal representation of women in some African literature is not unconnected with the patriarchal nature of Africa as a traditional society where women were considered as not being fit to take up heroic roles and therefore had to... more
The so-called “war on terror” has renewed the interest in torture in practice as well as in theory. The philosophical debate about possible justifications for torture has to a large extent revolved about the ticking time-bomb scenario:... more
Certain methods and weapons are traditionally considered to be 'mala in se', i.e. evil in themselves. Examples are mass rape campaigns and land mines. This article examines different interpretations of the principle that belligerents... more
Modern defense organisations are adopting AI quickly because it can read huge amounts of information, spot patterns, and produce options far faster than people can. But speed is not the same as good judgement. AI tends to miss the human... more
Yorùbá music is a reflection of its people's socio-cultural realities, encapsulates complex narratives of gender, power, and identity. This study examined the gendered discourses embedded within Yorùbá music by juxtaposing the works... more
by m m
Modern interstate warfare imposes costs in human lives, economic resources, and civilizational stability that consistently exceed the political objectives that triggered the conflict. Existing international frameworks — the UN,... more
If John II Komnenos has remained in the shadow of his father Alexios and his son Manuel, this is certainly not due to his insignificance as an emperor. It is rather due to the fact, already noted elsewhere in this volume, that unlike the... more
In this paper I argue that torture is morally justified in some extreme emergencies. However, I also argue that notwithstanding the moral permissibility of torture in some extreme emergencies, torture ought not to be legalised or... more
One of the most pressing issues related to our society is the failure of schools to adequately serve minority populations, including Hispanic students. Not only does this situation have harmful consequences for the students, it also... more
This anatomical review provides a thorough, multi-layered dissection of Advancing Military Practice through Military Humanities (Hagen & Enstad, eds., Routledge, 2026), the foundational text that formally inaugurates military humanities... more
This comprehensive analysis deconstructs the anatomy of command in the twenty-first century, arguing that the integration of artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML), and lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS) has established... more
The book offers a contemporary scholarly analysis of the Mahābhārata and Bhagavadgītā, exploring their enduring relevance and connecting the readers with rich Indian tradition. This work stems from the SPARC project, "Yoga Consciousness... more
There has always been a degree of tension between, on the one hand, the writings of philosophers, theologians and lawyers on the ethics of war, and, on the other, the moral approach of soldiers, those actually engaged in combat. The... more
תקציר המאמר: במאמר זה מוצג ניתוח ביקורתי של מושג "השוויון בנטל" בחברה הישראלית, תוך שימוש באנלוגיה השוואתית בין עולם הישיבות לבין מערכת המשפט המודרנית. המאמר מבקש לאתגר את השיח הציבורי המקובל, המבודד את לומדי התורה כקבוצה החורגת מהנורמה... more
In this paper I will argue that, the Gary Varner's practicable form of biocentrism relies on his two premises, of the priority of desire principle and priority of ground project principle. His priority of desire principle is open to... more
Traditional songs preserve historical happenings among the Yoruba people in the Southwestern part of Nigeria. Among these numerous songs, Ìjálá and Oríkìa song-texted usually chanted by traditional hunters and self-appraised song,... more
The global security landscape of the mid-2020s is defined by an unprecedented consolidation of economic, political, and military power, manifesting in a self-reinforcing system that prioritizes the expansion of defense capabilities as a... more
This paper examines the critical role of Hadith sciences ('Ulum al-Hadith) in preventing extremism and misinterpretation of Islamic texts. Through systematic analysis of authentication methodologies, contextual interpretation frameworks,... more