Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Textual Criticism

description8,593 papers
group39,068 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Textual criticism is the scholarly discipline that analyzes and evaluates the textual integrity and authenticity of written works, particularly historical manuscripts and literary texts. It involves comparing different versions of a text to establish its original form and to understand the processes of transmission and alteration over time.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Textual criticism is the scholarly discipline that analyzes and evaluates the textual integrity and authenticity of written works, particularly historical manuscripts and literary texts. It involves comparing different versions of a text to establish its original form and to understand the processes of transmission and alteration over time.

Key research themes

1. How do contemporary methodologies integrate computational and AI tools in advancing textual criticism?

This theme explores the application of computational models and AI-driven algorithms to support and refine textual criticism, particularly focusing on the identification of textual corruptions, error detection, and emendation in classical and premodern texts. It investigates the potential and limitations of machine learning and computational models in complementing traditional philological methods.

Key finding: The paper argues that standard literary criticism, grounded in discursive prose, fails to align with cognitive sciences' computational and formal methods. It advances the insight that literary critics should adopt... Read more
Key finding: Using the Princeton-based AI Logion, the authors demonstrate that large language models can accurately detect textual corruptions in Aristotle's transmitted texts and suggest plausible emendations. Significantly, even... Read more

2. What role does ideological and historical context play in shaping the transmission and interpretation of ancient texts in textual criticism?

This area examines how political, religious, and cultural agendas influence the textual production, transmission, and interpretation of ancient texts. It addresses how myths, national narratives, and reformist ideologies can shape the content and textual variants of foundational texts, and the implications for textual critics reconstructing original texts.

Key finding: The paper posits that the core theological and narrative elements of Deuteronomy and the Exodus story emerged as political and theological constructs in the royal court of King Josiah (ca. 640-609 BCE), not from ancient... Read more
Key finding: Echoing similar conclusions, this paper details how the Exodus narrative operates as a political allegory for Josiah's reign, embedding architectural and theological motifs as literary prototypes of the Jerusalem Temple. The... Read more

3. How do philological and manuscript studies reconstruct textual integrity through palaeography and analysis of manuscript variants?

Focusing on codicological and palaeographic methods, this theme investigates how scholars reconstruct original sequences and textual integrity from fragmented, misordered, or variant manuscript traditions. It encompasses analysis of scribal practices, manuscript material forms, and textual dislocations to illuminate text transmission and editorial history.

Key finding: Through palaeographic and textual analysis, the study reconstructs the sequence of leaves from a pre-fifteenth century homiliary dispersed across multiple manuscripts, revealing connections with similar homiletic collections.... Read more
Key finding: This paper identifies misordered bamboo slips in the 'Memoirs' section of the Shiji, arguing that Sima Qian compiled the text by excerpting earlier slips of roughly 21-23 characters each. The findings illuminate editorial... Read more
Key finding: By comparing two distinct transmissions of Hieronymus’s critique of Isocrates, the paper assesses textual fidelity and editorial layering in fragmentary literature. It reconstructs the relationship between the primary sources... Read more

All papers in Textual Criticism

by Rami I
This article argues that the Torah contains multiple versions of the same events and therefore cannot be treated as one perfectly preserved, unified text from the time of Moses. Building on Part One, this second part uses Richard Elliott... more
Workshop "Encoding Greek and Latin Lexica: Digital Models and New Research Frontiers", Sapienza Università di Roma, Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Antichità, 8-9 giugno 2026
AESCHYLEA PARVA a cura di M. Taufer PÀTRON EDITORE a cura di Matteo Taufer Vittorio Citti AESCHYLEA PARVA Vittorio Citti (Bologna, 6 novembre 1932-ivi, 13 dicembre 2023), formatosi sotto la guida di Antonio Maddalena e Carlo Del Grande, è... more
This study identifies the portion of patriarchal chronology that can be fixed with confidence and separates it cleanly from the portion that remains genuinely open. Working downward from the Exodus at 1446 BCitself fixed by three... more
For a classical editor orthography is both a straightforward and a demanding task. It is straightforward because readers tend to be more interested in the meaning of words and their relation to one another than in their written... more
This article presents a synthetic account of the author's research on Arabic and Coptic within a broader theoretical framework of the unity of the world. It examines language not as a fixed system but as a dynamic field shaped by... more
Why does Helen call herself “chilling,” “horrid,” and “dog-faced,” in situations where no one is blaming her? Why does Agamemnon accuse Odysseus of greed and enjoyment of wine without an apparent reason? Why do warriors in the Iliad... more
This research aims to shed light on the textual development of the Old Testament Peshitta in the books of Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. In these books, I have submitted the most important variants to study, verse by verse, with the... more
Este trabajo se propone explorar y analizar la política literaria que estructura Historia del llanto. La hipótesis que conducirá las formulaciones del mismo —y que se desprende de la doble pregunta en torno a la significación de: a)... more
Il contributo modella la banca dati Filmitalia per estrarre e processare quasi 4000 sinossi di film italiani usciti negli ultimi 25 anni. I dati raccolti vengono utilizzati per affrontare questioni di ricerca relative alla... more
(As delivered at Bristol CMS PGR Conference 2026) The conversion of the Sueves from Arianism to Catholicism in sixth-century Gallaecia represents a unique intersection of religious power and cultural performance within the early medieval... more
This presentation traces the development of the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) from ancient oral and written traditions to the medieval Masoretic codices. It highlights the role of scribes in preserving, editing, and transmitting Israel's... more
Modern historical-critical scholarship overwhelmingly relegates the Book of Daniel to a second-century BCE Maccabean context, viewing its narratives as late Hellenistic pseudepigrapha. This paper challenges that consensus by demonstrating... more
a datazione dell'Antiope di Euripide, posta al principio dell'ultima decade del quinto secolo da un noto scolio alle Rane di Aristofane, non è considerata sicura in ragione del calcolo statistico delle soluzioni del trimetro giambico.... more
This article seeks to reassess the intellectual profile of Laura Cereta (1469–1499) through a twofold analytical framework. First, it examines the paratexts composed by Jacopo Filippo Tomasini for his 1640 Paduan edition of Cereta’s... more
Articoli e schede proposti alla rivista sono preliminarmente valutati dal Direttore e dal Comitato di direzione; sono quindi sottoposti al parere vincolante di almeno un revisore esterno, che opera secondo il procedimento della revisione... more
Etymologicum Magnum s. v. κεραννύς (= 504, 25-35 Gaisford) attributes to a certain Pisander some information concerning the ancient custom of drinking horns. This notice is not included in the collection of fragments of either of the two... more
This is an English translation of a Czech paper originally published as a chapter in Od Mojžíše k novému Jeruzalému (2021). The text parallels between Mk and GTh are obvious at first glance. The shared vocabulary of both Gospels is often... more
dea che non fu mai muta e il dio che non parlò più. Tacita, Aius Locutius e le trappole della teoria 464 Vincenzo S U ,"Ius piscandi". Pesci e pescatori nel diritto romano .
This thesis examines how Sam Lake's narrative design evolves across Remedy Entertainment's major works (2001–2023) and how this evolution reshapes the player's role in constructing meaning. The thesis uses a formalist ludonarratological... more
Öz: Osmanlı toplumunun okuryazar kesiminin XIX. yüzyılda ana tartışma konusu medeniyet kavramı olmuştur. Bu tartışma XX. yüzyıl başlarında da devam etmiştir. Kavram ilerleme, cehaletten kurtulma, hürriyet, Batı kaynaklı bilim ve... more
Codex Augiensis is best known as one of a family of three Greek-Latin bilingual manuscripts grouped together because of similarities noted by scholars beginning in the 18th century. Scholars in the modern period have often concerned... more
Стаття є супровідною до книжки визначного літературознавця Віктора Дудка (1959-2015) про петербурзький журнал "Основу" (1861-1862), що підсумовує багатолітні студії науковця в цій ділянці. Проаналізовано працю Дудка над "Основою",... more
The Torah in the Light of Science and History: A Fresh Look at Selected Biblical Narratives is an original, dense, modern commentary on the Torah (the Five Books of Moses). This study closely examines and logically evaluates a selection... more
The “cross-readings” mentioned in the title refer to Petrarch’s habit of establishing connections between the texts he consulted and his own works; it alludes to the operation of intersecting data related to a corpus of Cicero’s... more
A 2023 book by Olivia Adankpo-Labadie-Moines, saints et hérétiques dans l'Éthiopie médiévale. Les disciples d'Ēwosṭātēwos et l'invention d'un mouvement monastique hétérodoxe (xive-milieu du xve siècle)-recapitulates and further elaborates... more
In *The Prince,* Niccolò Machiavelli re-writes the biblical accounts of Moses, David, and Goliath, and of God’s providence. These re-writings are a crucial part of his launching of modern political philosophy, which has decisively... more
In un articolo del 1932 sulla rivista «Nuova Antologia», Giuseppe Adami tratteggiava con efficacia i meccanismi della creatività di Puccini: un «sistema di ricerca continua del soggetto attraverso il teatro di prosa», in cui le... more
The Pericope Adulterae (PA), commonly known as the account of the woman caught in adultery found in John 7:53-8:11, is among the most beloved and widely cited passages in the New Testament. Yet a growing body of textual, linguistic, and... more
The Pericope Adulterae (PA), commonly known as the account of the woman caught in adultery found in John 7:53-8:11, is among the most beloved and widely cited passages in the New Testament. Yet a growing body of textual, linguistic, and... more
The Pericope Adulterae (PA), commonly known as the account of the woman caught in adultery found in John 7:53-8:11, is among the most beloved and widely cited passages in the New Testament. Yet a growing body of textual, linguistic, and... more
Nella storia dei Farnese l'età del Gran Cardinale Alessandro (1534-1589) corrisponde alla cruciale stagione di consolidamento della dinastia ai massimi livelli della società italiana e europea. La progressiva conquista di posizioni di... more
[This article is freely accessible at https://doi.org/10.1093/llc/fqag031.] In New Testament textual criticism, the paradigm of textual clusters has become a controversial subject. Within this paradigm, the traditional practice of... more
Os poemas espurios localizados en B e/ou V responden a dúas estratigrafías diferenciadas: unha primeira relativa aos textos que entraron na tradición manuscrita no momento en que se concluíu a última fase da «compilación xeral» (Oliveira... more
A contribución analiza a posibilidade de que unha expresión empregada como símil polos trobadores Johan Perez d'Aboim e Pero d'Ambroa en sendas tenzóns (o primeiro diríxea a Lourenço, o segundo a Johan Baveca) poida ser considerada unha... more
«Not Only China and Siberia»: In memory of Pavel M. Kozhin (1934–2016) / «不但是中國與西伯利亞»: 紀念帕維爾·米哈伊洛維奇·科任 (1934–2016): a collection of articles dedicated to the memory of the outstanding Russian archeologist, sinologist and ethnologist... more
Günümüz Osmanlı tarihçiliği “bolluk paradoksu” ile karşı karşıyadır: Bir yanda temel kaynakların neşri katlanarak artarken, diğer yanda alan metodolojik tutarlılıktan yoksundur ve tarihsel ile filolojik neşir pratikleri arasındaki... more
Alcuino, il maestro di Carlo Magno, si occupò di grammatica latina. I suoi studi non furono soltanto importanti per l'epoca, ma contengono degli approcci rudimentali alla sociolinguistica.
Traditionally, the comparison of textual witnesses is achieved through manual collation. This study introduces a computational approach adapting methods from bioinformatics: pairwise sequence alignment and dimensionality reduction, to... more
Erotic Themes Derived from the Decameron in Pier Paolo Vergerio’s Paulus. Regarded as the first example of humanistic comedy, Pier Paolo Vergerio’s Paulus is initially shaped by a pedagogical impulse inspired by Terence. Yet, as the play... more
Estudio y edición de un inédito de José Zorrilla, basado en una copia no autógrafa cobijada por el Archivo Municipal de Valladolid. El manuscrito –un poema histórico y anticlerical titulado «Roma»– ofrece una visión tópica sobre la... more
Download research papers for free!