The Will to Orthodoxy: a Critical Genealogy of Northern Chan Buddhism. By Bernard Faure, translated by Phyllis Brooks. pp. xii, 289, bibliography, glossary, index. Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1997. £37.50
Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, Apr 1, 2000
modern interpretation of Confucianism in China owes its origins to the (mis-)interpretations of t... more modern interpretation of Confucianism in China owes its origins to the (mis-)interpretations of the Jesuit visitors during the early Qing period. Shocking as it may read to the uninitiated, the "Confucian myth" forms part of the complex interaction between western and Chinese intellectuals during the Republican period. In its manifold expressions, the phenomenon has already been scrutinised from different angles: the role of the missionaries, the influence of western ideology, the role of the colonial powers. Jensen's contribution thus lies in the explicit analysis of the sources and of the subject matter. The book's biggest asset is at the same time also one of its major shortcomings: Lionel Jensen certainly invested a great deal of personal ambition into the topic. At times, his personal involvement creates the impression of using the monograph as a tool in a missionary struggle for the enlightenment of the scholarly community and the world beyond. Creating awareness among a public which has fallen prey to a centuries-old construct. A second corrective remark refers to the second, "modern" half of Jensen's contribution: the limited number of Chinese sources used inevitably leads to questions about the representative qualities of the two chosen authors. A broader presentation of the topic in the mirror of the early republican scholarly scene would have produced even more convincing evidence. Jensen's style is clear throughout, though the chapters are at times longer than necessary. A more concise presentation of the topic could have been achieved without sacrificing any of the impressive sources. Praise for the excellent and explicit appendix, with an encyclopaedic glossary of the terms used in the monograph. Alongside the bibliography, the glossary will help academics to orientate themselves through a philosophical corridor of more than four hundred years. Jensen's reflection on the interpretation of Confucianism in the modern world is on the whole a welcome contribution to the study of Chinese philosophy and to the pursuit of East-West crossfertilisation. By portraying modern perceptions of Confucianism in the West and in China as the outcome of western imagination and Chinese aspiration, Manufacturing Confucianism can indeed be referred to as a true "dispeller of myths".
Uploads
Books by James A Benn
Notices:Chronicle of Higher Education 53, no. 28, p. A21; Choice 45, no. 1 (September 2007), p. 115.
Reviews: Hanxue yanjiu tongxun (Newsletter for Research in Chinese Studies) 26, no. 3, August 2007, 55–56 [Stefania Travagnin] [electronic]; Middle Way 82, no. 2, August 2007, 119 [Simon Hui-Chiao]; Tang yanjiu 13, December 2007 [Chen Huaiyu]; Journal of the American Academy of Religion 76, March 2008, 198–202 [Natasha Heller] ; The Journal of Religion 88, no. 2, April 2008, 269–270 [Marcus Bingenheimer] ; Journal of Asian Studies 67, no. 2, May 2008, 678–681 [Wendi Adamek]; Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 69, no. 1, June 2009, 221–225 [Vincent Goossaert] ; Journal of Chinese Religions 36, 2008, 124–127 [Linda Penkower]; H-Buddhism, H-Net Reviews, November 2009 [Ryan Overbey]; Religious Studies Review 36, no. 3, September 2010, 193–198 [Liz Wilson].
Papers by James A Benn