Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Commingled Human Remains

description86 papers
group38 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Commingled human remains refer to the physical mixing of skeletal or other biological materials from multiple individuals, often resulting from natural processes, burial practices, or archaeological contexts. This phenomenon complicates the identification and analysis of individual remains, posing challenges for forensic anthropology, bioarchaeology, and legal investigations.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Commingled human remains refer to the physical mixing of skeletal or other biological materials from multiple individuals, often resulting from natural processes, burial practices, or archaeological contexts. This phenomenon complicates the identification and analysis of individual remains, posing challenges for forensic anthropology, bioarchaeology, and legal investigations.

Key research themes

1. How can skeletal measurements improve reassociation of upper limb bones in commingled human remains?

This theme centers on developing quantitative methods to reliably sort and re-associate disarticulated upper limb skeletal elements (scapulae, humeri, ulnae, radii) recovered from commingled contexts, such as mass disasters or multiple burials. Accurate reassociation supports biological profiling, including sex and stature estimation, in forensic and archaeological investigations where remains from multiple individuals are mixed. The key methodological advance lies in generating and validating regression equations based on linear measurements of articular surfaces, which can complement morphoscopic techniques to improve sorting precision and reduce investigator subjectivity.

Key finding: This study developed simple and multiple linear regression equations based on ten linear measurements of upper limb articular surfaces from 222 adult skeletons from the Athens Collection. The statistical models demonstrated... Read more
Key finding: Confirming the robustness of the approach, this near-identical replication demonstrated consistent measurement protocols and reinforced the validity of regression functions developed for re-associating scapulae, humeri,... Read more

2. What challenges and methods are involved in the excavation and identification of commingled human skeletal remains?

This research theme addresses the complexities and methodological considerations involved in the recovery, excavation, sorting, and biological profiling of commingled human remains, encountered in forensics, archaeology, and disaster victim identification scenarios. The focus is on stratigraphic complexity, taphonomic alteration, element representation, minimum number of individuals estimation, and integration of morphological, metric, and genetic evidence. Guidelines range from scene management to specialized recovery strategies, emphasizing case-specific adaptations due to variable depositional histories and preservation conditions.

Key finding: This guide synthesizes knowledge on commingled remains recovery emphasizing the necessity of context-specific strategies tailored to assemblage characteristics such as depositional duration, taphonomic processes, and scale of... Read more
Key finding: This case study illustrates practical challenges in forensic investigation of commingled child remains recovered from a dump site in Tanzania, including poor preservation, incomplete skeletal representation, and difficulty... Read more
Key finding: Through comparative decomposition trials with human and common nonhuman animal proxies, this study reveals that although pigs decompose more similarly to humans than rabbits, significant differences in decomposition... Read more

3. How does the context of commingled remains, including historical, forensic, and ritual settings, influence interpretation and identification?

This theme investigates how the contextual factors—ranging from prehistoric ritual dog-human burials, wartime mass grave discoveries, to forensic pathological evaluations of mummified or desiccated human remains—shape the interpretation, treatment, and identification of commingled skeletal remains. It bridges disciplinary perspectives on biological profiling, taphonomic processes, cultural funerary practices, and memorial significance, highlighting the interplay between scientific analyses and socio-historical narratives. Approaches integrate archaeological typologies, molecular characterization, and forensic methodologies to disentangle complex assemblages and ascertain individual and collective identities.

Key finding: This paper articulates a refined typology (adapted from Perri, 2017) to differentiate true dog burials (complete articulated skeletons deliberately interred) from elemental dog depositions (isolated bones in human graves),... Read more
Key finding: This interdisciplinary study employed FTIR spectroscopy and GC-MS to chemically characterize embalming residues on bandages and coffin interiors, confirming the association of a mummified female individual with a set of three... Read more
Key finding: Based on 102 forensic autopsy cases with indoor desiccated remains, this study characterizes the progression of skin and soft tissue mummification patterns and their correlations with postmortem interval (PMI), showing that... Read more
Key finding: The study underscores the juridical ambiguity surrounding World War I and II soldier remains in France, which lie between forensic anthropology and archaeology. It advocates for holistic identification approaches combining... Read more

All papers in Commingled Human Remains

W trakcie akcji Reinhardt w południowo--wschodniej Polsce Niemcy zastosowali dwoistą strategię masowych mordów. Podczas gdy większość Żydów została deportowana do obozu zagłady w Bełżcu, pozostałe osoby rozstrzeliwano w pobliżu gett.... more
Tokom 2016. godine sprovedena su zaštitna arheološka istraživanja na lokalitetu Pirivoj, koji obuhvata prostor istočno od legijskog logora u Viminacijumu. Ovim iskopavanjima obogaćena su dotadašnja znanja o istočnoj nekropoli, kroz... more
Mortuary practices in southern Greece undergo a radical transformation at the beginning of the Mycenaean era (or Late Bronze Age, around 1700 BCE). This period sees the introduction of formal cemeteries, larger tombs, richer burials and a... more
Mortuary practices in southern Greece undergo a radical transformation at the beginning of the Mycenaean era (or Late Bronze Age, around 1700 BCE). This period sees the introduction of formal cemeteries, larger tombs, richer burials and a... more
Se presentan los resultados del análisis de los restos humanos y los necrosuelos recuperados en el sitio Mortero Hachado (Trancas, Tucumán) durante los años 1996-1999. Debido a la escasa información contextual y a que el conjunto se... more
This chapter will explore the lives and deaths of men interred in a cemetery located in the Phalero delta, beyond the walls of Athens, where Attica meets the sea. Sources indicate that Attic Greece at this time was struggling overall with... more
Archaeological research often documents the discovery of human remains in settlements, regardless of the period concerned. They are found in pits dug for this very purpose or in domestic pits reused after their original function (e.g.... more
Historia KL Warschau łączy dwa istotne wydarzenia z dziejów okupowanej stolicy: zakończoną powstaniem w getcie zagładę warszawskich Żydów i Powstanie Warszawskie. Zasługuje więc na szczególną uwagę, w czym pomóc może publikacja IPN... more
Th e notion of person among the Maya has been studied particularly for the Classic and post-contact periods. However, we know little about the Maya person in the Postclassic period. In this paper, our initial assumption is that the... more